Photo Criticism
Information
A place to receive constructive criticism on photos. Upload a photo to this group if you want to find out what you did wrong or what you could do better.
Members: 970
Latest Activity: 4 hours ago
If you would like to get constructive criticism on one of your photos here is what you do.
1. Click the Link that says "Start a Discussion"
2. Upload your photo to the "Post" section on the "Start a Discussion" screen. To do this click on the little photo icon next to the text formatting icons.
3. After your photo is uploaded you might add some text under it if you wish describing what you are concerned about or what you would like to hear opinions about.
4. Please do not use the attach section because then users will have to click on a link to your photo to see it. By using the "Post" section, users can study your photo more effectively.
Discussion Forum
Como Conservatory 3 Replies
Tagged: Conservatory, Como
Started by Doverkamp. Last reply by Vito 4 hours ago.
Fly Away 3 Replies
Fairy wings for sale at the Hoggetowne Medieval Faire in Gainesville, Florida
Tagged: Gainesville, Florida, Faire, Medieval
Started by Rob Bixby. Last reply by Rob Bixby 4 hours ago.
Appreciate critical comments on the pic below 2 Replies
Hi all, I am interested in night photography. This photo was taken of a party lawn lit during night time. Would appreciate critical comments/ways to improve so that I can enhance my night photograph…
Tagged: lit, wonderfully, lawn, party, A
Started by Havneet Pal Singh. Last reply by Havneet Pal Singh 11 hours ago.
A long night - Comments please 1 Reply
I took this last weekend using a home made snoot. I quite like it but should have used a darker room and longer exposure to make the flames bigger. What do you think? Thanks Richard
Started by Richard Amor-wilkes. Last reply by nathan mccreery 23 hours ago.
How does this look? 2 Replies
Tagged: Conservatory, Como
Started by Doverkamp. Last reply by Ed Harp 23 hours ago.
squigle 2 Replies
just a photo i took ages ago wondered what everyone's thoughts were.
Started by Rhys Brooks. Last reply by Dennis Lauer 1 day ago.
Portfolio Material TAKE TWO 9 Replies
alright so i posted a photo befor ( a picture of a back with a black bra) i got some crit. on it and so im trying again... dont hold back, but dont be too hars lol. soo, what do you think? portfolio…
Tagged: black, white, love, respect, beauty
Started by wojomojo. Last reply by Mark Lawrence 1 day ago.
trike 5 Replies
Just a shot I've been thinking about, and thought I'd float it out there.Thank you for your comments/suggestions.
Started by Dennis Lauer. Last reply by Dennis Lauer 1 day ago.
F15 on static under Stormy skies 4 Replies
Opinion's please?This is a shot taken on a rather rainy Sunday afternoon at 2009's RIAT airshow.There were not may opportunities to take many pictures this particular day. This image has been manipul…
Started by Paul Watson. Last reply by nvfriendly Feb 7.
Chicago Sky Wicked 5 Replies
Trying something different.
Started by Mike Lamb. Last reply by nvfriendly Feb 7.
do you think this photo is portfolio material?? 8 Replies
I'm currently trying my hardestttttt! To get into this one art school for college and I really want to have as many strong pieces as possible. I dont plan on attending for photography but I wish to…
Tagged: skin, white, black, bra, back
Started by wojomojo. Last reply by wojomojo Feb 6.
young at heart 13 Replies
this was taken inside a not so well lit store, portrait of and old man who sells ice cream for a living, what made me took his photo was the lights on the side of his face from the reflection of the…
Started by Jan Michael Vincent V Castillo. Last reply by Sean Feb 6.
SINULOG 2010 4 Replies
taken during the solemn mass in honor of the child Jesus, the Señor Sto. Niño de Cebu..... for your Comments and Criticisms....
Started by Rhoel. Last reply by Rhoel Feb 5.
LIFE @ THE DUMPSITE 6 Replies
Please feel free to input your Comments and Criticisms to help improve the photos....
Started by Rhoel. Last reply by Rhoel Feb 5.
Venice at sunset 15 Replies
My first acquaintance with the colors of the nature...
Started by Arzu M.S.. Last reply by Rachel Michaels Feb 5.
Little girl and flower 7 Replies
Hey all, Been pretty busy lately but here's one I took today in a session. Backlit by a 72" octabox, settings were 1/125sec, f20, 100iso. I edited it in PS7. It's been a while since I've done th…
Started by William J. Dabovich. Last reply by William J. Dabovich Feb 4.
Comment Wall
Comment
-
Comment by Ed Harp 1 day ago -
Wojomojo,
The words on the body don't seem to match the intense lighting/shadowing and pose which to me speaks more of suffering and pain. Unless the message conveyed is this person's desire for love, respect, peace, and beauty. Many in this fallen world carry a lifetime of hurt and abuse and this might work for such an illustration. Interesting
-
Comment by wojomojo on February 6, 2010 at 5:37pm -
opinions anyone?
-
Comment by Mohammed Al Maskary on February 5, 2010 at 12:15pm -
-
Comment by Mohammed Al Maskary on February 5, 2010 at 12:03pm
-
-
Comment by wojomojo on February 5, 2010 at 11:39am
-
is this photo portfolio material??
-
Comment by Ed Harp on February 3, 2010 at 8:15pm
-
Tanvir,
The balance falls to the left too much. If the bottom flower remains where it is, the top flower then needs to be moved to the top right to provide a counter force which pulls your eye to the opposite corner of the frame. The flower on the bottom should be sharp stamens to petals. I don't know what your aperture setting was, but maybe one of f/16 at minimum might create enough DOF.
-
Comment by Ed Harp on February 3, 2010 at 8:07pm
-
Samantha,
here's what I see in your image
-
Comment by Allan Mathew on January 30, 2010 at 7:02am
-
Pls see my blog on expressions of sky
http://photographywithpassion.blogspot.com/
-
Comment by Rob Bixby on January 28, 2010 at 3:25pm -
Samantha, the only thing I can think of that image needing is to straighten it.
Keith, first, you should try to never put the horizon in the middle of the image. It makes the eye try to find one side that is more dominant than the other. Usually, either the sky, or the water/landscape has more visual interest than the other. Shift the horizon up or down as appropriate. Otherwise, there's not a lot that I find interesting about the image. The structures are obviously the point of interest, but not enough so to catch me, sorry.
-
Comment by Tanvir Ali on January 28, 2010 at 2:52am -
how can i make this better?
Camera: Nikon L18
Rules and Terms of Service
Resources
Badge
Help Support this Site
© 2010 Created by PictureSocial.com
You need to be a member of Photo Criticism to add comments!