Innes McCallum's Page

Innes McCallum replied to Innes McCallum's discussion Working On My Composition. Please Help. in the group Photo Criticism

"Hi Ian. Thanks for the feedback again. I love the way your boats photograph draws you in. Did you vignette it slightly? Cause the dark corners really pull me in to it. I need to try and make more use of the sky and light to pull the eye into my…"

Dec 24, 2009

Randall Sherman replied to Innes McCallum's discussion Working On My Composition. Please Help. in the group Photo Criticism

"Listen to Ian! His remarks are good and to the point. I will add a bit. Composition splits into pre-click considerations and post-click considerations. For the B&W, you could have improved the pre-click by getting the camera higher. The shutter…"

Dec 24, 2009

Ian Clark replied to Innes McCallum's discussion Working On My Composition. Please Help. in the group Photo Criticism

"The boats are better for me. The boats work because they have good lead in lines that your eyes follow into the photo - well done. Once your eyes are 'in' the photo the sun on the sides of the buildings hold them momentarily which gives…"

Dec 24, 2009

Innes McCallum added a discussion to the group Photo Criticism

Working On My Composition. Please Help.

Any feedback would be greatly appreciated. Thanks!!See More

Dec 24, 2009

3 Comments 0 Likes

Innes McCallum posted photos

Dec 24, 2009

Innes McCallum replied to Innes McCallum's discussion Landscape photography feedback in the group Photo Criticism

"This really helps Ian. I took so many different pictures of the city scape but couldn't work out why I wasn't completely happy. I'm trying to work hard on composition. It's an ongoing development. Thanks for taking the time to…"

Dec 24, 2009

Mike Hiler commented on Innes McCallum's photo

Highland cow

"There can be only one!! :) Mike :)"

Dec 22, 2009

nathan mccreery replied to Innes McCallum's discussion Feedback Wanted

"I'm not in love with either of images and I am at a loss as to what I would do to change them. I think the thing that I am dealing with is that they are so similar to so many photographs I seen. One of the things i would encourage you to do is…"

Dec 21, 2009

Ian Clark replied to Innes McCallum's discussion Landscape photography feedback in the group Photo Criticism

"Innes great effort and thanks for posting, hopefully you learn from this feedback and remember you can reject it a well as accept it but never be offended. My general comment is to thing about photos like art, if you look at the great painters…"

Dec 21, 2009

Sean replied to Innes McCallum's discussion Feedback Wanted

"Love the colors in the first one, but both of these images have one thing in common, the horizon it right in the middle. Makes it a bit hum drum. The b&w, the sky isn't breath taking, so work more with the water's reflection or maybe a…"

Dec 20, 2009

Innes McCallum and Randall Sherman are now friends

Dec 20, 2009

Innes McCallum commented on Innes McCallum's photo

DSC_0019_2

"Thanks Randall. It took a bit of trial and error to get it right."

Dec 20, 2009

Innes McCallum replied to Innes McCallum's discussion Landscape photography feedback in the group Photo Criticism

"Thanks Nathan I tried re-shooting a similar cityscape at sunrise and was more pleased with the results but still needs more work. See below. "

Dec 20, 2009

Randall Sherman commented on Innes McCallum's photo

DSC_0019_2

"I love your camera position in this shot! A few inches higher, lower, more left or more right wouldn't be as balanced. Great job!"

Dec 20, 2009

nathan mccreery replied to Innes McCallum's discussion Landscape photography feedback in the group Photo Criticism

"I have never cared much for silhouettes so the second photograph doesn't do a lot for me. The reason is that we see silhouettes so much. It could be more effective, in my view, if there were information in the dark parts of the land. Next, my…"

Dec 20, 2009

Innes McCallum posted photos